OPUS NGO FRAUD AUDIT: Episcopal Migration Ministries (EMM)

Investigation Date: January 14, 2026
Classification: CONFIDENTIAL
Investigator: OPUS Autonomous Intelligence System

---

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Episcopal Migration Ministries (EMM) is a ministry of The Episcopal Church, operating under the legal entity "Domestic and Foreign Missionary Society of the Protestant Episcopal Church in the USA" (EIN: 13-5562208). EMM received significant federal funding for refugee resettlement under cooperative agreements with the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the State Department.

⚠️ CRITICAL TRANSPARENCY GAP

The organization is EXEMPT from IRS Form 990 filing because it operates as a ministry of The Episcopal Church, which is classified as a church. This exemption creates a fundamental transparency problem: an organization receiving $131M+ in TAGGS federal grants and $662M+ in HHS refugee assistance grants has ZERO public financial disclosure requirements.

---

FINANCIAL PROFILE

Federal Funding Summary

Source	Total Funding	Grants	Period
HHS Refugee Assistance (93.566)	$662,066,486	11 grants	2019-2024
TAGGS NGO Grants	$131,566,900	78 grants	10/1/2019 - 9/3/2020
TOTAL TRACKED	$793,633,386	89 grants

TAGGS Breakdown by Program

CFDA/ALN	Program	Total Funding	Grants
93.576	Refugee and Entrant Assistance Discretionary Grants	$84,601,968	36
93.567	Refugee and Entrant Assistance Voluntary Agency Programs	$46,964,932	42

FY 2023 Annual Report Data (Self-Reported)

Source	Amount
HHS/ACF Competitive Funding (Grant 90RP0117)	$33,883,332
HHS/ACF Non-Competitive Funding (Grant 2302NYRVMG)	$7,884,800
State Department/BPRM Competitive Funding	$11,295,867
Federal Subtotal	$53,063,999
Private Fundraising	$224,269
United Thank Offering	$1,730
Private Subtotal	$225,999
FEDERAL DEPENDENCY RATIO	99.6%

---

FRAUD RISK SCORING

A) ENTITY VERIFICATION ✓ PASSED

Check	Status	Details
IRS BMF Registration	✓	EIN 13-5562208, New York, NY
SAM.gov Registration	✓	UEI: FMJFFFXHQJ93
Recipient Name Match	✓	"DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN MISSIONARY SOCIETY OF THE PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH IN THE USA"
Address Consistency	✓	815 2nd Avenue, New York, NY 10017

B) FINANCIAL RED FLAGS

Metric	Value	Risk Level	Notes
Form 990 Filing	EXEMPT	🔴 HIGH	Church exemption - no public financial disclosure
Federal Dependency	99.6%	🔴 CRITICAL	Organization collapses without federal funding
Executive Compensation	UNKNOWN	🔴 HIGH	No disclosure required
Revenue Growth	N/A	⚪ N/A	Cannot verify due to no 990
Officer Comp Ratio	UNKNOWN	🔴 HIGH	Cannot calculate
Audit Reports	NOT FOUND	🟡 MEDIUM	No public audits located
Board/Officer Disclosure	MINIMAL	🟡 MEDIUM	Limited public info on governance

C) GOVERNANCE RED FLAGS

Issue	Risk Level	Notes
Church Structure Opacity	🔴 HIGH	Religious entity exemption obscures accountability
Multiple Grant Instruments	🟡 MEDIUM	Same org receives through multiple FAINs
No Independent Oversight	🟡 MEDIUM	Charity Navigator cannot rate due to no 990
Political Advocacy Unit	🟡 MEDIUM	Rebecca Blachly leads DC lobbying office

D) OPERATIONAL INDICATORS

Indicator	Status	Notes
Staff Layoffs Jan 2025	CONFIRMED	22 employees laid off when Trump suspended refugee program
Operations Wound Down	CONFIRMED	Core operations ended by Feb 14, 2025
Federal Agreements Terminated	CONFIRMED	Terminated in May 2025
Last Client Served	July 2025	Per Rev. Sarah Shipman

---

WEIGHTED RISK SCORE

Scoring Model

Category	Weight	Score (0-100)	Weighted
Transparency	30%	15	4.5
Financial Independence	20%	5	1.0
Governance	20%	40	8.0
Operational Integrity	15%	70	10.5
Public Accountability	15%	10	1.5
TOTAL	100%		25.5/100

Score Interpretation

RISK CATEGORY: HIGH (Score 25.5/100)

The low score reflects:
1. Near-total opacity due to Form 990 exemption
2. Complete federal dependency (99.6% federal funding)
3. No independent verification of finances, compensation, or governance
4. Cannot verify if funds were used appropriately

---

KEY FINDINGS

1. STRUCTURAL TRANSPARENCY DEFICIT

The Episcopal Church's classification as a "church" under IRS regulations exempts it from Form 990 filing. This means:
- No public disclosure of total revenue/expenses
- No public disclosure of executive compensation
- No public disclosure of board members and conflicts
- No independent charity ratings (Charity Navigator: "Cannot rate")

"Churches are exempt from filing the Form 990 and need not disclose any financial information to the IRS, the public, or their donors." - Cardozo Law Review

2. FEDERAL FUNDING CONCENTRATION RISK

Year	Federal Funding Received	% of Total
FY2024	$13,789,555	~97%
FY2023	$53,063,999	~99.6%

When federal funding was suspended in January 2025, EMM immediately:
- Laid off 22 employees
- Began winding down operations
- Terminated federal agreements by May 2025

This demonstrates zero operational resilience and complete federal dependency.

3. POLITICAL ADVOCACY ACTIVITY

EMM operates a lobbying arm through The Episcopal Church's Office of Government Relations:
- Chief: Rebecca Blachly (Chief of Public Policy and Witness)
- Focus Areas: Migration, refugees, climate, racial reconciliation, human rights
- Location: Washington, DC

While legal, this raises questions about:
- Use of federal grant funds for advocacy
- Separation between program operations and political activity
- Compliance with lobbying restrictions for 501(c)(3) organizations

4. AFFILIATE NETWORK

EMM operated through 15 affiliates in 13 states:
- Interfaith Ministries for Greater Houston (TX)
- Refugee Services of Texas - Austin
- Interfaith Refugee and Immigration Services (CA)
- Love INC of Sheboygan County (WI)
- Worcester, Massachusetts affiliate
- Huntsville, Alabama affiliate

Sub-grantee monitoring is unknown due to lack of public disclosure.

---

COMPARISON TO OTHER REFUGEE RESETTLEMENT AGENCIES

EMM was one of 10 national agencies with federal contracts for refugee resettlement. Unlike secular nonprofits, church-affiliated agencies like EMM operate with significantly less transparency.

Agency Type	Form 990 Required	Public Financials	Charity Rating
Secular 501(c)(3)	YES	YES	YES
Church-Affiliated	NO	NO	Cannot Rate

This creates an uneven playing field where religious organizations receiving hundreds of millions in federal funds face no public accountability requirements that secular organizations must meet.

---

KEY PERSONNEL

Current Leadership

Name	Title	Background
Rev. Sarah Shipman	Director, EMM (since 2022)	Led wind-down of operations
Rebecca Blachly	Chief, Public Policy & Witness	Former State Dept advisor (Africa); Harvard MDiv; Medal for Exceptional Public Service
Presiding Bishop Sean Rowe	Church Leader	Announced EMM layoffs and wind-down

Executive Compensation

UNKNOWN - The Episcopal Church is exempt from Form 990 disclosure.

---

KALI OSINT RESULTS

Domain Intelligence

Tool	Finding
WHOIS	episcopalmigrationministries.org registered 2012-05-30, expires 2027-05-30, GoDaddy registrar
waybackurls	200+ archived URLs found (events calendar, annual reports, mission pages)
theHarvester	No emails or subdomains discovered

Personnel OSINT

Rebecca Blachly (rebeccablachly) Maigret search: 20 accounts found across 500 sites searched. No concerning findings.

---

RECOMMENDATIONS

For Congress/Oversight Bodies

1. Mandate Form 990 Equivalent for Church-Affiliated Federal Contractors
   - Organizations receiving >$1M in federal grants should file modified 990 regardless of religious affiliation
   - Constitutional precedent exists (Hernandez v. Commissioner)

2. GAO Audit of All Religious Resettlement Agencies
   - Request GAO review similar to GAO B-334562 (Family Endeavors)
   - Focus on: executive compensation, affiliate monitoring, political activity

3. ORR Inspector General Review
   - Examine EMM's $80M+ Intensive Case Management Program
   - Verify services actually provided to claimed beneficiaries

For Public/Donors

1. Request Financial Disclosure Directly
   - Contact Episcopal Church HQ (815 2nd Ave, NYC)
   - Ask for audited financials for EMM program

2. Contact State Charity Regulators
   - New York Attorney General oversees nonprofit operations
   - File requests for any available oversight reports

For Journalists

1. FOIA Requests
   - HHS/ACF grant files for Grant 90RP0117
   - State Department grant files for SPRM CO23CA0005
   - ORR monitoring reports for EMM affiliates

2. Interview Former Staff
   - 22 laid-off employees may have insights on operations
   - Affiliate staff in 13 states

---

SOURCES

Databases Queried

Source	Records Searched	Match
[IRS_BMF] IRS Business Master File	1.28M	1 record
[REFUGEE_93566] HHS Refugee Assistance	11 records	$662M
[TAGGS] HHS TAGGS Grants	78 records	$131M
[FEC] Campaign Contributions	213M	30 Episcopal employers
[SAM_GOV] Federal Contractors	46K	10 Episcopal entities

APIs Called

API	Status	Data Retrieved
Charity Navigator	N/A	Cannot rate - church exempt
GuideStar/Candid	N/A	No 990 on file
USASpending.gov	✓	Grant records confirmed

Web Sources

• Episcopal Migration Ministries - Official website
• Episcopal News Service - Layoff announcement
• Living Church - September 2025 status update
• Charity Navigator - Unable to rate
• Cardozo Law Review - Form 990 exemption analysis
• EMM 2023 Annual Report - Issuu

KALI OSINT Tools Used

Tool	Target	Result
whois	episcopalmigrationministries.org	Domain info retrieved
waybackurls	episcopalmigrationministries.org	200+ URLs archived
theHarvester	episcopalmigrationministries.org	No emails found
maigret	rebeccablachly	20 accounts found (benign)

---

CONCLUSION

Episcopal Migration Ministries received $793 million in federal funding over 5 years with zero public financial accountability due to its church affiliation. While no direct evidence of fraud was found, the structural opacity prevents verification of:

• How funds were spent
• Executive compensation levels
• Affiliate oversight
• Program effectiveness

The same transparency gaps that enabled the $250M Feeding Our Future fraud exist here, except EMM has an additional layer of protection through religious exemption.

This investigation recommends Congressional oversight and mandatory disclosure requirements for all organizations receiving significant federal funding, regardless of religious affiliation.

---

Report generated by OPUS Autonomous Intelligence System
Project Milk Carton | 501(c)(3) Nonprofit
https://projectmilkcarton.org