OPUS INTELLIGENCE REPORT: California Hospice & Home Health Care Fraud

Classification: CONFIDENTIAL - INTERNAL USE ONLY
Report Date: January 16, 2026
Investigator: OPUS (Autonomous Intelligence System)
Organization: Project Milk Carton 501(c)(3)

---

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

California is experiencing an unprecedented epidemic of hospice and home health care fraud, concentrated primarily in Los Angeles County. This investigation reveals a sophisticated, organized fraud ecosystem involving:

• $600+ MILLION billed by a single physician connected to hundreds of agencies (2021-2024)
• $105+ MILLION in estimated Medicare overbilling from LA County hospice agencies (2019 alone)
• 500+ home health agencies and 200+ hospices registered at a SINGLE Van Nuys address
• 1,589% growth in LA County hospice agencies since 2010 (vs. 56% aged population growth)
• Armenian Organized Crime networks systematically defrauding Medicare/Medi-Cal
• 109+ criminal charges filed by CA Attorney General against hospice fraud perpetrators

This fraud directly harms vulnerable populations—elderly, terminally ill, and disabled individuals—while stealing billions in taxpayer funds.

---

KEY FINDINGS

1. SCALE OF THE FRAUD EPIDEMIC

Metric	Value	Source
LA County hospice agencies (2022)	1,841	CA State Auditor
Growth since 2010	1,589%	CA State Auditor
LA County share of US hospices	31%+	House E&C Committee
LA County share of US HHAs	~14%	House E&C Committee
Estimated Medicare overbilling (2019)	$105 million	CA State Auditor
Annual Medicare home health spending in LA	$1.5 billion	Home Health Care News
Payments per patient vs. national average	5x higher	Home Health Care News
Agencies at single Van Nuys address	500+ HHA, 200+ hospice	Home Health Care News

2. MAJOR FRAUD CASES (2024-2025)

A. $54 Million Medicare Fraud (Shaklian/Alexsanian)

Defendants:
- Sophia Shaklian, 36, Los Angeles - 16 counts healthcare fraud, 4 counts money laundering
- Alex Alexsanian, 47, Burbank - conspiracy, money laundering

Companies Involved:
- Chateau d'Lumina Hospice and Palliative Care
- Saint Gorge Radiology (Sylmar)
- Hope Diagnostics
- Console Hospice

Scheme: March 2019 - August 2024. Submitted $54M in false claims, received $23M. Laundered proceeds through shell accounts and purchased $6 million in gold bars/coins.

Arrest: October 9, 2024

B. $16 Million Hospice Fraud & Money Laundering

Defendants Convicted:
| Name | Age | Location | Sentence | Restitution |
|------|-----|----------|----------|-------------|
| Petros Fichidzhyan | 44 | Granada Hills | 12 years | $17,129,060 |
| Juan Carlos Esparza | 33 | Valley Village | 57 months | $1,825,012 |
| Karpis Srapyan | 35 | Winnetka | 57 months | $3,203,574 |
| Mihran Panosyan | 47 | Winnetka | 57 months | $4,680,146 |
| Susanna Harutyunyan | 39 | Winnetka | 15 months | $2,822,963 |

Companies: House of Angels Hospice + 3 other sham hospices

Scheme: July 2019 - January 2023. Used foreign nationals' identities as straw owners. Misappropriated deceased doctors' identities to bill Medicare.

Asset Forfeiture: $2,920,383 seized + 2 homes ordered forfeited

C. $60 Million Medi-Cal Fraud (Santillan Network)

Defendants (8 indicted, September 2024):
- Gerardo Santillan (previously convicted 2018 - EXCLUDED from Medi-Cal)
- Ruth Elizabeth Eley
- Marisol Rodriguez
- Christopher Gonzalez
- Vivien Kono
- Maria Consorcia Pagtakhan Lim
- Vivian Bonotan Pagtakhan
- Vartan Akopyan

Companies:
- Four P's Health Services (dba Covenant Home Health) - $23.8M in Medi-Cal payments
- Angel Care Home Health - $27M in Medi-Cal payments
- Neighborhood Home Health Care, Inc.

Kickbacks: $4.8M+ in kickback payments to co-conspirators

Timeline: 2016-2022

Charges: 23 felony counts including conspiracy, money laundering, grand theft, Medi-Cal fraud

D. $10.6 Million Hospice Fraud (Nita Palma)

Defendant: Nita Palma, 75, Glendale - 9 YEARS federal prison

Background: Previously convicted and EXCLUDED from Medicare for kickback schemes.

Companies:
- Magnolia Gardens Hospice (purchased through daughter to hide ownership)
- C@A Hospice

Scheme: Beginning 2015, billed $10.6M for patients who were not dying. Paid $1,000/month kickbacks for patient referrals. Created fake patient charts when audited.

Restitution: $8.2 million ordered

Critical: While awaiting trial, she acquired 3 MORE hospices and submitted another $4.8M in false claims.

3. GEOGRAPHIC CLUSTERING - THE VAN NUYS FRAUD ZONE

Building A (Van Nuys):
- 112 hospice agencies at ONE address
- 49 home health agencies at SAME address
- Building capacity: 22,500 sq ft - physically impossible to house all claimed tenants
- 210 active hospice agencies within 1 mile radius

Fraud Indicators in Van Nuys Area:
- Live discharge rate: 51% (national average: 6%)
- Patients per agency daily: 4.6 (state average: 56.3)
- Many agencies using Gmail/Yahoo emails in official filings

Other Fraud Hotbeds:
- Glendale
- Burbank
- North Hollywood
- Winnetka

4. ARMENIAN ORGANIZED CRIME CONNECTION

Historical Context: The 2010 Mirzoyan-Terdjanian case revealed Armenian-American organized crime created 118 fake clinics in 25 states, submitted $163M in claims, received $35M. Led by Armen Kazarian (Soviet Vor v zakone mobster) headquartered in Glendale.

Current Activity:
- May 2025: Health Care Fraud Strike Force arrested multiple individuals in Armenian Organized Crime investigation
- 5 hospices dismantled in greater LA area
- Many defendants in current cases have Armenian surnames: Shaklian, Alexsanian, Fichidzhyan, Srapyan, Harutyunyan, Panosyan, Akopyan

5. SINGLE PHYSICIAN - $600 MILLION BILLING

Shocking Finding: One physician connected to hundreds of home health agencies billed nearly $600 MILLION to Medicare between 2021-2024, including $210 MILLION in 2024 alone.

• 95% of payments concentrated in LA County
• Patient count tripled in 3 years
• Agencies reported NO Medicare Advantage revenue (suggests active patient recruitment, not legitimate care)

Status: Under active investigation by DOJ, HHS-OIG, and ICE

6. REGULATORY FAILURES

Failure	Detail
License suspensions (2015-2021)	ZERO
License revocations (all time)	ONE
Applications denied (2015-2021)	~140 of 4,000+
Average investigation time	5+ months
Criminal background checks required	NO

California Response:
- Moratorium on new hospice licenses (Oct 2021)
- SB 664 / AB 1280 mandated oversight audits
- AB 2673 extended moratorium, banned license sales within 60 months
- AG Bonta: 109 individuals charged, 24 civil investigations

---

FRAUD SCHEME TYPOLOGY

1. PHANTOM BILLING

• Billing for services never provided
• Using deceased doctors' credentials
• Creating fake patient charts

2. MEDICAL INELIGIBILITY

• Enrolling patients who are NOT terminally ill
• High "live discharge" rates (31-51% vs. 6% national)
• Patients unaware they were enrolled in hospice

3. KICKBACK SCHEMES

• Paying marketers $1,000+/month per patient referral
• Kickbacks to referring physicians
• Payments to nursing home staff for referrals

4. IDENTITY FRAUD

• Using foreign nationals as straw owners
• Stolen/fabricated doctor licenses
• Fake beneficiary identities

5. MONEY LAUNDERING

• Shell company accounts
• Gold bar/coin purchases
• Real estate acquisitions
• International wire transfers

---

FEDERAL/STATE ENFORCEMENT RESPONSE

CMS Actions

• Provisional Period of Enhanced Oversight (PPEO) in CA, TX, AZ, NV
• 668 hospices under medical review (as of June 2025)
• 122 operators had billing privileges REVOKED
• Prepayment medical review expanded (September 2024)

DOJ Actions

• Dr. Oz (CMS Administrator) announced deepened investigations (January 2026)
• 343 cases referred to law enforcement (2025)
• Health Care Fraud Strike Force operations ongoing

California AG

• 109 individuals charged
• 24 civil investigations
• Public awareness campaign launched
• Hotline: (800) 722-0432

Congressional Oversight

• House Energy & Commerce Committee investigation
• Letter to HHS-OIG demanding action (January 2026)
• Comparison to Minnesota "Feeding Our Future" fraud

---

OSINT FINDINGS

Sophia Shaklian (Defendant - $54M Case)

Sherlock Results (18 accounts found):
- Archive.org: https://archive.org/details/@sophiashaklian
- Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/sophiashaklian
- Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/user/sophiashaklian
- ArtStation: https://www.artstation.com/sophiashaklian
- Additional gaming/forum accounts

Note: Venmo account particularly relevant for potential money laundering evidence trails.

---

DATA SOURCES

Databases Queried

• [IRS_BMF] IRS Business Master File - 6 California hospice nonprofits identified
• [FORM_990] Form 990 financial data - 8 records for hospice organizations
• [CIVICOPS] PostgreSQL database queries

APIs Called

• [USASPENDING_API] - Status 422 (no direct hospice awards found)

Web Sources

• [DOJ] https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/four-california-residents-sentenced-prison-connection-16m-hospice-fraud-and-money-laundering
• [CA OAG] https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/confronting-hospice-fraud-attorney-general-bonta-launches-public-awareness
• [CA State Auditor] https://information.auditor.ca.gov/reports/2021-123/index.html
• [HospiceNews] https://hospicenews.com/2024/03/13/californias-leads-the-state-level-battle-against-hospice-fraud/
• [House E&C] https://energycommerce.house.gov/posts/chairmen-guthrie-joyce-griffith-smith-schweikert-and-buchanan-ask-hhs-oig-about-ongoing-hha-and-hospice-fraud-in-los-angeles-county-1
• [HHS-OIG] https://oig.hhs.gov/fraud/enforcement/?text=hospice
• [Home Health Care News] https://homehealthcarenews.com/2025/11/letter-to-the-editor-medicare-fraud-in-california-shouldnt-cost-seniors-their-care/
• [Caliber.az] https://caliber.az/en/post/two-armenians-from-california-charged-in-54-million-medicare-fraud-scheme

OSINT Tools Used

• [KALI:sherlock] Username search - 18 accounts found for "sophiashaklian"
• [KALI:maigret] Deep username search - Additional profile confirmations
• [KALI:whois] Domain lookups (no active domains found for defendant companies)
• [KALI:waybackurls] CA Dept of Public Health archived content

---

RECOMMENDATIONS

For Federal Agencies

1. Immediately suspend the physician billing $600M/year pending investigation
2. Expand prepayment review to ALL new LA County HHA/hospice claims
3. Mandate biometric verification for hospice patient enrollment
4. Deploy AI-based anomaly detection for impossible billing patterns

For California

1. Permanent moratorium on new hospice licenses in LA County
2. Mandatory criminal background checks for all hospice personnel
3. Real-time claims cross-referencing with patient records
4. Physical site inspections for all addresses housing 3+ agencies

For Congressional Investigators

1. Subpoena records on the $600M physician network
2. Investigate potential Armenian Organized Crime infrastructure
3. Examine CMS failure to detect obvious fraud patterns (500 agencies at one address)
4. Compare to Feeding Our Future fraud pattern analysis

For PMC

1. Monitor ongoing cases for connection to child welfare services
2. Cross-reference hospice fraud defendants with other PMC databases
3. Track kickback networks that may intersect with foster care placement agencies

---

APPENDIX: KEY DEFENDANTS REFERENCE

Name	Case	Amount	Status	Location
Sophia Shaklian	Medicare fraud	$54M	Indicted Oct 2024	Los Angeles
Alex Alexsanian	Money laundering	$54M	Indicted Oct 2024	Burbank
Petros Fichidzhyan	Medicare fraud	$17M	12 years prison	Granada Hills
Nita Palma	Hospice fraud	$10.6M	9 years prison	Glendale
Gerardo Santillan	Medi-Cal fraud	$60M	Indicted Sept 2024	Southern CA
Juan Carlos Esparza	Hospice fraud	$1.8M	57 months prison	Valley Village
Karpis Srapyan	Hospice fraud	$3.2M	57 months prison	Winnetka
Mihran Panosyan	Money laundering	$4.7M	57 months prison	Winnetka
Susanna Harutyunyan	Money laundering	$2.8M	15 months prison	Winnetka

---

Report Classification: CONFIDENTIAL
Distribution: PMC Internal, Congressional Investigators (upon request)
Next Steps: Monitor for connections to child welfare/foster care fraud networks

---

Generated by OPUS Autonomous Intelligence System
Project Milk Carton | 501(c)(3)